Skip to Main Content
Ditch old-school procurement. Upgrade to RFP Automation.
Your guide to eliminating the mini-bid grind.
See it in action
Back to Resources

People vs. Machine: Striking the Perfect Balance in Transportation Management

People vs. Machine: Striking the Perfect Balance in Transportation Management

In today’s fast-paced world of logistics and supply chain management, technology has revolutionized the way we handle operations. Machine learning and artificial intelligence (AI) have emerged as invaluable tools, streamlining processes, enhancing efficiency, and improving decision-making — capabilities that have made some in the industry very nervous. 

Fears of job displacement and loss of control due to AI-powered automation have taken hold among many in the industry, however as powerful as AI may be, it’s important that businesses don’t lose sight of the value that a human touch brings to keeping their shipments (and their business) on track. 

From decision-making and oversight to data collection and customer interaction, human workers provide essential inputs to the operation of a complex supply chain network. Rather than being replaced, their expertise and abilities are complemented by AI systems, ensuring a holistic and responsible approach to transportation. The collaboration between humans and AI leads to improved outcomes, increased safety, and enhanced user experiences in the transportation domain.

To achieve that collaboration, a balance between AI and human workers in transportation management needs to be found, and in order to do that we need to dive into what both bring to the table. 

Leveraging AI’s Strengths

AI and machine learning specifically have undeniably transformed transportation management by providing unmatched speed, accuracy, and scalability. Here are a few ways AI empowers supply chain professionals:

1. Data Analysis and Predictive Insights: AI algorithms can analyze vast amounts of data in real-time, identifying patterns, trends, and anomalies. This helps in forecasting demand, improving pricing strategies, optimizing routes, and improving overall operational efficiency.

2. Automating Repetitive Tasks: AI-powered automation minimizes the time spent on manual data entry, documentation, and administrative tasks, freeing up human resources to focus on more strategic and complex responsibilities.

3. Enhanced Decision-Making: AI-driven analytics and intelligent algorithms provide valuable insights, enabling more informed decision-making. From demand forecasting to exception management, AI assists in making data-driven choices that boost efficiency and reduce costs.

The Human Advantage

While AI excels at handling repetitive and data-driven tasks, it cannot replace the unique abilities and qualities that humans bring to the table. Here’s why the human touch is indispensable in transportation management:

1. Decision-Making: Humans are responsible for setting goals, defining policies, and making critical decisions related to transportation systems. They establish regulations, infrastructure development plans, and safety guidelines that AI systems must adhere to. Humans also define the ethical considerations and legal frameworks that govern the use of AI in transportation.

2. Intuition and Emotional Intelligence: AI lacks the ability to understand and respond to human emotions, which can be crucial in customer service and building relationships. Human workers bring empathy, emotional intelligence, and a personal touch that strengthens client interactions and improves customer satisfaction.

3. Adaptability and Flexibility: In the dynamic world of logistics, adaptability is essential. Humans can quickly adapt to changing circumstances, adjusting strategies and finding solutions on the fly. AI, on the other hand, relies on pre-programmed algorithms and may struggle when faced with unexpected situations.

4. Data Collection and Labeling: AI systems rely on the careful collection and curation of data from the people operating them. For example, any paper documentation on delivery instructions, special handling requirements, or customer preferences needs to be collected and deciphered by human workers. They also play a vital role when it comes to assessing special handling requirements or labeling and annotating the datasets used for training AI algorithms (ex. identifying objects in photos for inventory management). Accurate and diverse data collected by humans is crucial for training AI models effectively.

Achieving the Perfect Balance

To harness the full potential of technology while benefiting from human capabilities, it’s essential to strike the perfect balance. Here are some strategies for integrating AI and the human touch effectively:

1. Collaboration, Not Replacement: Rather than seeing AI as a replacement for human workers, view it as a collaborative tool that enhances their capabilities. Encourage collaboration between humans and AI, leveraging the strengths of each to achieve optimal results.

2. Continuous Learning and Upskilling: As AI continues to evolve, it’s crucial for transportation management professionals to stay updated and acquire new skills. Companies should invest in training programs to equip their workforce with the knowledge and expertise required to work alongside AI effectively.

3. Focus on Relationship Building: While AI can streamline processes and automate tasks, it’s important to remember that human connections remain invaluable. Prioritize building strong relationships with clients, partners, and suppliers, leveraging the human touch to foster trust and loyalty.

What’s next?

The partnership between AI and humans is expected to evolve and transform over time. Here are some potential trends and areas of development for this partnership:

Collaboration and Integration

AI systems will become more integrated into everyday tasks and activities, working alongside humans as collaborative tools. Rather than replacing humans, AI will augment human capabilities, assisting in decision-making, automating repetitive tasks, and providing valuable insights based on data analysis. Humans will continue to provide the necessary oversight, ethical considerations, and context understanding.

Enhanced Trust and Transparency

As AI becomes more pervasive in transportation and other domains, there will be a greater emphasis on building trust and transparency between humans and AI systems. Efforts will be made to make AI more explainable and interpretable, ensuring that humans can understand the reasoning behind AI decisions. Humans will also play a role in validating AI outcomes, verifying accuracy, and addressing biases or errors.

Ethical and Responsible AI

The partnership between AI and humans will evolve towards a more ethical and responsible approach. Humans will take an active role in defining ethical guidelines, setting regulations, and establishing accountability frameworks for AI systems. Considerations such as privacy, fairness, safety, and the impact on society will be crucial in shaping the evolution of AI and its partnership with humans.

Continuous Learning and Adaptability

AI systems will continue to improve through continuous learning and adaptation, driven by human feedback and expertise. Humans will provide the necessary training data, validate and refine AI models, and guide their development to align with evolving needs and preferences. This iterative process will result in AI systems that better understand human intentions and respond more effectively to complex scenarios.

Evolving Roles and Skillsets

The partnership between AI and humans will lead to a shift in roles and skillsets. Humans will increasingly focus on tasks that require creativity, critical thinking, emotional intelligence, and ethical decision-making, while AI systems handle more routine and data-driven tasks. This shift will require humans to acquire new skills, such as data analysis, AI literacy, and the ability to collaborate effectively with AI technologies.

Addressing Societal Impact

The partnership between AI and humans will involve a continuous examination of its societal impact. Humans will be responsible for addressing concerns related to job displacement, fairness, inequality, and the overall well-being of individuals and communities. Collaboration will be necessary to ensure that AI technologies are developed and deployed in a manner that benefits society as a whole.

By embracing the strengths of both AI and human effort, companies can unlock new levels of efficiency, innovation, and customer satisfaction in their supply chain operations. So, let us celebrate the synergy of technology and humanity, where AI serves as a remarkable tool, but human intelligence, intuition, and empathy continue to shape the future of transportation management.

Find your balance

Schedule a demo today to discover how Shipwell unlocks greater efficiency, cost savings, and customer satisfaction through balanced collaboration between technology and the people who put it to work.